Missing The Point on Race Isn’t A Bug; It’s A Feature


Breaking: this man has stupid things to say about race.

There may be no bigger example of deliberate and pernicious point-missery than the fake controversy around Black Lives Matter. At this point, anyone who says, “well, actually, I think all lives matter” is purposefully ignoring that “all lives matter” is the very point of BLM, in which the “matter” is doing the real heavy lifting. Indeed, the pseudo-ecumenical sophist is doing nothing more than maintaining a brutal status quo, in which black lives, especially black male lives, matter very little.

The thing is, that’s exactly the point. We saw this over the weekend, where many of the usual suspects followed the lead of Joe Walsh, only a little more toned down. (except, sort-of-interestingly, Newt Gingrich, though Pierce puts to rest the idea of Newt, man of reason.) There is perhaps no more surprising headline than the one in the Times this morning: “Rudolph Giuliani Lashes Out At Black Lives Matter.”

Giuliani has spent an entire career playing fast and loose with race and with white backlash. Anti-homeless and anti-squeegee campaigns were signifiers: you can take New York back (and make it great again). His police force saw many instances of shocking violence, and most of the steps that made the city safer were the result of positive action taken by his predecessors. That isn’t to say he didn’t do anything well, but his form of local authoritarianism was always more than slightly-tinged with race. Now that he is clearly never running for anything again, since America made it clear in 2008 that simply having been mayor on September 11th doesn’t qualify you for the big job, he’s free to unfurl his proudest banners.

“When you say black lives matter, that’s inherently racist,” Mr. Giuliani said in an appearance on CBS’s “Face the Nation.” “Black lives matter. White lives matter. Asian lives matter. Hispanic lives matter. That’s anti-American, and it’s racist.”

“They sing rap songs about killing police officers, and they talk about killing police officers, and they yell it out at their rallies and the police officers hear it,” he said.

Right, the raps! The rap singers with their rap songs!

Actually, you know what? While it’s always fun to make fun of people who say things like “they sing rap songs”, it’s actually sort of important, and not just because Giuliani is out of touch (as, to be clear am I). This is also deliberately missing the point, and doing so in a way that shifts responsibility. The anger inherent in some music is a reaction, not a cause, but it serves the purposes of race-baiters and reactionaries like Rudy to pretend otherwise.

It’s part and parcel of the execrable and odious charge that BLM is “inherently racist.” Saying that they shouldn’t stand up and say “our lives matter too” puts the onus back on the black people to accept what is happening to them, to accept a country that for hundreds of years has enslaved, hanged, oppressed, segmented off, red-lined, unjustly incarcerated for cheap labor, and murdered black lives. And well yes, as Giuliani and others point out, more black lives are taken by other black people, that’s also the point. We treat that as something terrible happening in some blighted community, and not as a national fucking tragedy. Not as something inherently wrong with America, but just with black people, who usually don’t live near the rest of us. We take a tongue-clucking anthropological remove, and then get offended when a movement demands of us not to.

This demand to get back in line is seen in other examples of point missing, like when Dan Patrick, Texas’s lunatic Lt. Governor (which seems to be the breeding ground of horrible people), said this:

“All those protesters last night, they ran the other way, expecting the men and women in blue to turn around and protect them. What hypocrites,” Patrick said on Fox News. “I understand the First Amendment. I understand freedom of speech, and I defend it. It is in our Constitution and is in our soul, but you can’t go out on social media and mainstream media and everywhere else and say that the police are racist or police are hateful or the police are killers.”

That’s perfect: the BLM protesters are hypocrites because they expect the police to do their jobs at all times. They expect to be protected by the police when there is danger, but also expect not to be unfairly harassed or arrested or beaten or murdered. Pick one or the other, hypocrites!

It’s easy to make fun of Patrick. But he’s not wrong, per se: he’s articulating a very clear worldview. If you are black, you should always listen to the police. The responsibility for your safety is in your hands, and that is unquestioning obedience. That’s the code. Police have power over all of us, but especially if you are poor or a minority. Then they have life and death power, always, and you have to respect that, and fear it, and don’t expect to change anything. When they say shut up, you better not think they said stand up, because then you’re dead. If you want even the barest modicum of protection — if you want police to do their jobs — then the price is unquestioning subservience, no matter what.

Again, these aren’t bugs in the thinking. It’s the whole point. For a lot of right wingers, the point of the police is to keep Them from Us, using whatever means needed. Reaction to that injustice is a deliberate provocation, and should be quashed. (This attitude is not the case, I should say, for the huge majority of the police, as you can see in the reaction in the Giuliani story).  That’s their story, and it is an American story. I won’t return the favor and say that’s just a right-wing problem. It’s part of our eternal and inescapable tragedy.

2 thoughts on “Missing The Point on Race Isn’t A Bug; It’s A Feature

  1. Pingback: Reacted to the Gun: Yemen and the US; National Security and the Illusion of Exceptionalism | Shooting Irrelevance

  2. Before I begin, I would like to make a few things explicitly clear:
    1. I am not Anti BLM, nor am I a conservative.
    2. I do believe that racial profiling is a big deal and is prevalent. Moreover, I believe that black people are shot and killed unfairly without trial and that it’s a reprehensible action.
    3. My critiques of BLM are mainly aimed at the supporters, not the movement as a whole.

    Now let me start off by asking a question: You claim that All Lives Matter is redundant because BLM has the same goal already. If that is true, then why is the group named Black Lives Matter? As I said before, blacks have been treated unfairly, but how could you claim that BLM cares about everyone, but yet has a name that puts all emphasis on one group of people?

    Second: I agree that Rudi Gulianne is an out of touch idiot, plus that the NYPD has done some reprehensible things. But he touched on something important, the rap music. While he addressed it very incompatantly, allow me to make my case. I’ve listened to a lot of rap music, and while it does touch on other subjects, a lot of it glorifies violence, drug use, and promotes a some would argue degrading treatment of women. Now I personally don’t believe that the music of a group defines them, but it would appear to me that many BLM supporters are big fans of this image and this lifestyle. Do you or do you not think that this could feed into the stereotype that black people are violent, poor, and rude? I wouldn’t think people who think Black Lives Matter would agree with such a dipiction.

    Third and lastly, I hesitate to support a group that claims to care about black people, but either denies and in some cases attack you for believing that blacks kill other blacks at a much higher rate than all other groups put together. It’s not a secret why this happens: Mass Poverty, almost complete absences of fathers, and perpetual gang violence. Many BLM advocates blame white people for all of these issues, but I largely disagree. I think it more has to do with the irresponsible single black mothers who has more kids than she could possibly take care of on a fixed income (mainly welfare.) By this continuing, it brings black kids into the world in crippling poverty in which they grow up to either get involved with gangs, become overwelmed to the point where they feel there’s no escape, or simply choose not to. If BLM truly believes that Black Lives Matter, they would be passionate to do everything in their power to help these people. Yet all of their actions done so far has given black people a worse name in the eyes of the public. How is celebrating the death of police officers going to save these people? How is yelling “Fry’em like bacon!” going to feed these people? How I’d destroying city blocks going to solve the poverty crisis?

Keep it respectful...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s